Friday, November 9, 2012

THE SHADOW SCHOLAR PONDERING THE LIGHT AND “DARK SIDE” OF HOW WE WORK



The discussion between good and evil peaks at this time of year in India, today being VijayDashami – the day the fabled true King Rama triumphed over the evil Ravaana who had kidnapped his wife in revenge for his sister’s insult. It could have been a complicated story, but the unidimensional characters make it an easy stories for a values based education session. The Ramayana, being one of the traditional epics has been used in schools and reading sessions for years as a salutary tale on the consequences of evil. Leaving aside its Hindu connection (which is difficult given the current saffronised scenario), it is a valuable exploration into pedagogical tools for an exploration of values. Pitching right against wrong is something we do all the time
I wrote papers for students for ten years. I helped them cheat and I made a living doing it. Not a great living, but a living nonetheless.Now, I’m retired from paper-writing and it feels good. I feel like a recovering drug addict, like I’m standing up and telling you about my sordid past.
As in many tales of drug-induced excess, I have seen things that would horrify the clean-living among you. But I’m not referring to the cheating, the dishonesty or even the general crappiness of some colleges. I got used to all of that stuff, even desensitized to it for a time.
Something that I never got used to, to which I never felt desensitized, which I even suspected was getting worse all the time, was the declining stock of students infiltrating our system of higher education. I am, by no means, an elitist. I don’t have the income for it. But I find it disturbing that we have so recklessly diluted the pool of students who are deemed college-worthy. Quality control is a thing of the past, due at least in part to the turnstile magic of No Child Left Behind.

No comments: