August 15, 2009 · Leave a Comment
The lack of blood being splattered strongly indicates that TBH was dead by the time he exited the window. Hence, no sign of struggle.
In the haste to dispose his body, one of BH’s shoes could have come off. The victim’s trousers then got entangled to the window latch. And as it broke, the victim fell – the weight of his body tearing his trousers. The shoe was later thrown down to make it look as though it is part of the suicide.
I have a strong feeling some of the evidence may have been tampered with. Therefore it makes it difficult for us to second quess exactly what happened the night BH died.
Who asked Dr Khairul whether the deceased jumped or was pushed? I think it was the private lawyer acting for the A-Gs chambers. Gobind was cross-examining. the suicide conclusion made by dr.khairul was pre-arranged. What are the material facts that dispelled this theory ?
a. It was difficult for teoh to push himself backwards given that there were hardly any ledge for him to stand on. The horizontal velocity suggested a initial horizontal force.
b. His broken belt buckle and torn shirt on his right side suggested that he was lifted up from his belt buckle and right side of his shirt. This also suggested that the person who threw teoh out of the window was right handed.
c. The absence of smudges on the window sill meant he did not climb out himself.
d. The position of teoh’s body where he landed on his right thigh indicated a slight twist to teoh’s right side. This is consistent with the theory that he was thrown out. As the right hand has to throw a larger mass than the left hand it created a slight torque to teoh’s body.
e. The lack of defensive wound suggested that teoh was unconscious when he exited the window.
—–
The torn heart muscles was caused by the tremendous compressive force. If such force could tear the heart muscles it could easily tear the pants.
—–
The lack of blood in falling from such height could be explained from the point of impact. If he had landed on his head or body the blood spill would be large. If he had landed on his legs or in this case his thigh bone much of the force had been absorbed by the breaking thigh and leg bones.
But then it dawn upon me that the whole thing could be a sandiwara or charade on the government side. All the while they wanted an ‘accidental fall’ or ’suicide verdict’ (remember the Selangor CPO almost immediately announced that there was no foul play after the body was found). So lawyer Tan and Dr. Khairul could have ‘pakat’ or conspired before the hearing telling him the question that he’ll be asking and Dr. Khairul should point to a ’suicide’ conclusion. Since Dr Khairul is the pathologist who did the PM, the public are expected to believe this BS. But the people rejects this blatant charade and will never rest until the truth is told.As far Doc, I seem to have missed the information that a matching thread from TBH’s pant was found at the window.
When I do a search, I only find this:
“Another witness, Saiful Fazamil Mohd Ali attached with the criminalistic section of the Forensic Department said he analysed a screw, window latch with three screws, metal clip, a watch and a connecting pin, a button with a white thread, a pants, which was covered with blood, a part of a doormat and a piece of paint.”
and this:
“He (Mazli) said he also did not find any fabric threads at the window frame on the 14th floor, where the Selangor headquarters of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) is located.”
So I think you have received a wrong information.from experience the foreign pathologist, if not allowed on the stand, will pass on her observations to Teoh’s group of lawyers. She will tell them what to ask and debunk some of the finding of Dr Khairul.
Honestly, I don’t trust this Khairul fellow. I reckon he has done PM on many lock-up deaths and has never found the police culpable. He is a police frindly pathologist.
Many of these doctors always give finding favourable to the police.
Tell me, was there ever once the police were found culpable for the more than 1500 deaths in police custody?
We have murders covered up by police, doctors, AG chambers, judges and the government.
This people and their progeny will receive Divine retribution for this evil.Death at MACC: My CSI X: The window and Dr Khairul
15/08/2009 by drrafick
1. The window at the MACC office on the 14th floor became the issue of contention during the inquest. The forensic expert says that the window is dusty but there were no prints on the window. The floor near the window is carpeted and is also dusty. Dr Khairul in his theory says that TBH committed suicide based on his findings at the window and the condition of the window.
2. Respectfully I have to disagree with Dr Khairul even though I do not have the access to the information and material that Dr Khairul had. Despite the minimal information initially and with the latest information that is being released via the inquest, I find that Dr Khairul suggestion that TBH may have commit suicide a little bit farfetched.
3. I believe Dr Khairul and I are on the same page with regards to the cause of death which is immediate death upon impact from a fall from height. The underlying cause would be massive and sudden blood loss in the chest cavity and the torn heart muscle. His own PM finding rules out the possibility of stroke or heart attack.
4. However I disagree with him on the manner TBH exited the window. From earlier discussion and inquest findings, it is quite certain now that the exited point is the window on the 14th floor where the broken latch and a matching thread from his pants was found.
5. Let us revisit what was said by CI Mazli Jusoh at the Inquest. Among others he said,” he found no visible signs of shoe prints on the window ledge or nearby walls” and “The window frame was dusted for fingerprints but the results were negative because the window was dirty and dusty,” The main crux of the police findings here is that there was dust at the window frames and it has not been disturbed. There were no markings on the window frames as if someone had touched it.
6. Based on Mazli Jusoh statement, it is quite probable that he did not climb out. If he did then, there would be marks on the window frames. It is almost impossible for someone of TBH height to climb out the window without holding to the frames. He is not that tall and has a body length of 174cm (5 feet and 8 inch).
7. Based on DSP Shahrul statement at the inquest where he said that he measured the window size which is 132cm in height and 82 cm in width. From the pictures on the internet, I measured the pixel points and estimated that the height of the window base from the floor is about 85cm. This rough measurement basically tells us that the window height is about 49% of Teoh body length.
8. It would be difficult for anyone of that size to climb out of the window without holding on to the side of the windows. The measurement ratio between the height of the window base from the floor and TBH height alone is conclusive enough that Dr Khairul theory that he had committed suicide is very weak and can be thrown out of the window.
9. Personally, I feel Deo has been an unfair to Dr Khairul. As a doctor, the most he can comment is the nature of the injury, its severity and postulated the cause and time of death. He probably can contribute to the mechanics of the injury. Obviously, he does not have all the pieces of the puzzle. It is a question should have been addressed to the I/O.
10. The absences of any disturbance of dust distribution on the window frames actually strengthen two important points. The first point is that he was either dead or was unconscious at the time he was exiting the window and the second is that there is a strong possibility that was lifted and thrown out of the window.
11. The basis of my argument on Para 10 is based on the fact that if TBH was lifted into the window, that there isn’t any need for anyone touch the frames of the window. Therefore there would be no disturbance in the dust marking on the window frames. This is consistent with what the police finding on the window frames.
12. At the same time, I am not sure how many people read the PM by Dr Khairul. My own observation is that there are a few findings that in my mind may not be associated with the fall. I will dwell more into this matter in the coming days. So far in my mind, based on the PM findings, the many pictures on the internet and the revelation at the inquest, I am more inclined to believe that TBH died while he was in the custody of MACC. I firmly believe that he was dead or unconscious when he exited the window.
Link to Inquest records at AG Chambers website
Disclaimer
The above writing is based on assessment of various images and writings on the mainstream media (MSM) as well as the online media. I am trying to understand the tragedy that took place at Plaza Masalam. It would be great if I have access to MACC office and location where the body was found but without such access, readers can expect some gross margin of error in my writing. Do let me know what the errors are so that we can come to a clear conclusion on what transpired.
police had a hand in the rape and murder of two women in Shopian town in doctors did not take out all required samples from heart and brain of the girl Asiya and her pregnant sister-in-law Neelofar Jan for FSL tests during the postmortem.
read this how the police protect their own kind
SRINAGAR: The Jammu&Kashmir government on Friday admitted that the police had a hand in the rape and murder of two women in Shopian town inThe report, which was submitted to Chief Minister Omar Abdullah on July 8 by Justice (retd) Muzzafar Jan, was vetted by the state law department before taking the decision.Kashmir Valley has been seething after a 17-year-old girl and her 22-year-old sister-in-law were found dead in a stream on May 30 in Shopian. The police and the state government first said the women had drowned.The four suspended police officers in connection with the case will be treated as accused and interrogated by the Special Investigating Team set up by the state government.State finance minister Abdul Rahim Rather changed his government’s stand and told a press conference in Srinagar that a judicial probe had implicated the state police in the murders.Accepting the judicial commission’s recommendation, the state government also announced that a separate case would be registered against the former SP of Shopian Javed Iqbal for allegedly lying on oath before the Commission. Besides Iqbal, the one-member Commission said DySP Rohit Baskota, SHO Shafiq Ahmed and Sub-inspector Gazi Abdul Rehman were also responsible for destruction of evidence.Rather said a complaint had been filed against four police officials for destruction of evidence in the deaths. The state government urged people in the state to remain calm and assured them those found guilty of the murders won’t be spared.Two people have been killed and more than 400 others injured in numerous angry protests and clashes between demonstrators and police, especially in Shopian, 60 kms from Srinagar.Those who use the media filter to try to understand what is happening in Kashmir should realize they’re looking at a shadow play. A curtain lies: A judge who was tasked with investigating the Shopian rapes and killings that snowballed into huge protests and left the governmentred-faced has held the J&K police and the state administration responsible for destroying evidence.In his report submitted on Sunday, Justice Muzaffar Ahmad Jan said the police and civil administration had erased all links that could have helped the panel to reach the culprits. The bodies of the two women, who residents of Shopian, 50 km from Srinagar, claim were raped and then killed by security forces, were found in a lake last month.The panel held four top police officers, including former Shopian SP Javid Iqbal, DSP Rohit Baskot, former SHO Shakil Ahmad and SI Gazi Abdul Karim responsible for trying to hush-up the case and make it look like a case of accidental drowning. Chief minister Omar Abdullah on Monday ordered suspension of the four officers. Javid was recently transferred to Ramban in Jammu following largescale resentment against him in Shopian.After protests erupted, Abdullah on June 1 asked the retired judge to probe the rape and murder that occurred on the intervening night of May 29-30.IG, CID, Farooq Ahmad will hold a departmental inquiry against these police officers, sources said. Jan told TOI that the doctors, who conducted the post-mortem, also tried to hush up the case by holding back the report for six days.He observed scientific officer at the Forensic Science Laboratory Javed Iqbal Hafiz also delayed the submission of certificate containing opinion of the doctors regarding rape. Abdullah has also suspended Hafiz.Jan said the doctors did not take out all required samples from heart and brain of the girl Asiya and her pregnant sister-in-law Neelofar Jan for FSL tests during the postmortem.In the 150-page report, Justice (retired) Jan recommended departmental action and inquiry against the doctors. He also recommended prosecution of Javid Iqbal Hafiz, scientific officer of FSL, for obstructing and delaying investigations by deliberately keeping the FSL report with himself.He also recommended disciplinary action against former deputy commissioner Shopian Mohammad Ramzan Thokar for inaction.“I have recommended stern disciplinary action against the former deputy commissioner Shopian for not giving orders for registering an FIR,” Justice Jan said. Quoting the medical report, Justice Jan said the rape was committed on the women before they were killed.between events and us. What is played out on the screen depends on who manipulates the sources of light.
SRINAGAR: The Jammu&Kashmir government on Friday admitted that the police had a hand in the rape and murder of two women in Shopian town in
The report, which was submitted to Chief Minister Omar Abdullah on July 8 by Justice (retd) Muzzafar Jan, was vetted by the state law department before taking the decision.
Kashmir Valley has been seething after a 17-year-old girl and her 22-year-old sister-in-law were found dead in a stream on May 30 in Shopian. The police and the state government first said the women had drowned.
The four suspended police officers in connection with the case will be treated as accused and interrogated by the Special Investigating Team set up by the state government.
State finance minister Abdul Rahim Rather changed his government’s stand and told a press conference in Srinagar that a judicial probe had implicated the state police in the murders.
Accepting the judicial commission’s recommendation, the state government also announced that a separate case would be registered against the former SP of Shopian Javed Iqbal for allegedly lying on oath before the Commission. Besides Iqbal, the one-member Commission said DySP Rohit Baskota, SHO Shafiq Ahmed and Sub-inspector Gazi Abdul Rehman were also responsible for destruction of evidence.
Rather said a complaint had been filed against four police officials for destruction of evidence in the deaths. The state government urged people in the state to remain calm and assured them those found guilty of the murders won’t be spared.
Two people have been killed and more than 400 others injured in numerous angry protests and clashes between demonstrators and police, especially in Shopian, 60 kms from Srinagar.
Those who use the media filter to try to understand what is happening in Kashmir should realize they’re looking at a shadow play. A curtain lies: A judge who was tasked with investigating the Shopian rapes and killings that snowballed into huge protests and left the government
red-faced has held the J&K police and the state administration responsible for destroying evidence.
In his report submitted on Sunday, Justice Muzaffar Ahmad Jan said the police and civil administration had erased all links that could have helped the panel to reach the culprits. The bodies of the two women, who residents of Shopian, 50 km from Srinagar, claim were raped and then killed by security forces, were found in a lake last month.
The panel held four top police officers, including former Shopian SP Javid Iqbal, DSP Rohit Baskot, former SHO Shakil Ahmad and SI Gazi Abdul Karim responsible for trying to hush-up the case and make it look like a case of accidental drowning. Chief minister Omar Abdullah on Monday ordered suspension of the four officers. Javid was recently transferred to Ramban in Jammu following largescale resentment against him in Shopian.
After protests erupted, Abdullah on June 1 asked the retired judge to probe the rape and murder that occurred on the intervening night of May 29-30.
IG, CID, Farooq Ahmad will hold a departmental inquiry against these police officers, sources said. Jan told TOI that the doctors, who conducted the post-mortem, also tried to hush up the case by holding back the report for six days.
He observed scientific officer at the Forensic Science Laboratory Javed Iqbal Hafiz also delayed the submission of certificate containing opinion of the doctors regarding rape. Abdullah has also suspended Hafiz.
Jan said the doctors did not take out all required samples from heart and brain of the girl Asiya and her pregnant sister-in-law Neelofar Jan for FSL tests during the postmortem.
In the 150-page report, Justice (retired) Jan recommended departmental action and inquiry against the doctors. He also recommended prosecution of Javid Iqbal Hafiz, scientific officer of FSL, for obstructing and delaying investigations by deliberately keeping the FSL report with himself.
He also recommended disciplinary action against former deputy commissioner Shopian Mohammad Ramzan Thokar for inaction.
“I have recommended stern disciplinary action against the former deputy commissioner Shopian for not giving orders for registering an FIR,” Justice Jan said. Quoting the medical report, Justice Jan said the rape was committed on the women before they were killed.
between events and us. What is played out on the screen depends on who manipulates the sources of light.READMORE CLICK BELOW
Justice (retired) Jan recommended departmental action and inquiry against the doctors.,Javid Iqbal Hafiz, scientific officer of FS Lobstructing ,
The lack of blood being splattered strongly indicates that TBH was dead by the time he exited the window. Hence, no sign of struggle.
In the haste to dispose his body, one of BH’s shoes could have come off. The victim’s trousers then got entangled to the window latch. And as it broke, the victim fell – the weight of his body tearing his trousers. The shoe was later thrown down to make it look as though it is part of the suicide.
I have a strong feeling some of the evidence may have been tampered with. Therefore it makes it difficult for us to second quess exactly what happened the night BH died.
Who asked Dr Khairul whether the deceased jumped or was pushed? I think it was the private lawyer acting for the A-Gs chambers. Gobind was cross-examining. the suicide conclusion made by dr.khairul was pre-arranged. What are the material facts that dispelled this theory ?
a. It was difficult for teoh to push himself backwards given that there were hardly any ledge for him to stand on. The horizontal velocity suggested a initial horizontal force.
b. His broken belt buckle and torn shirt on his right side suggested that he was lifted up from his belt buckle and right side of his shirt. This also suggested that the person who threw teoh out of the window was right handed.
c. The absence of smudges on the window sill meant he did not climb out himself.
d. The position of teoh’s body where he landed on his right thigh indicated a slight twist to teoh’s right side. This is consistent with the theory that he was thrown out. As the right hand has to throw a larger mass than the left hand it created a slight torque to teoh’s body.
e. The lack of defensive wound suggested that teoh was unconscious when he exited the window.
—–
The torn heart muscles was caused by the tremendous compressive force. If such force could tear the heart muscles it could easily tear the pants.
—–
The lack of blood in falling from such height could be explained from the point of impact. If he had landed on his head or body the blood spill would be large. If he had landed on his legs or in this case his thigh bone much of the force had been absorbed by the breaking thigh and leg bones.
But then it dawn upon me that the whole thing could be a sandiwara or charade on the government side. All the while they wanted an ‘accidental fall’ or ’suicide verdict’ (remember the Selangor CPO almost immediately announced that there was no foul play after the body was found). So lawyer Tan and Dr. Khairul could have ‘pakat’ or conspired before the hearing telling him the question that he’ll be asking and Dr. Khairul should point to a ’suicide’ conclusion. Since Dr Khairul is the pathologist who did the PM, the public are expected to believe this BS. But the people rejects this blatant charade and will never rest until the truth is told.As far Doc, I seem to have missed the information that a matching thread from TBH’s pant was found at the window.
When I do a search, I only find this:
“Another witness, Saiful Fazamil Mohd Ali attached with the criminalistic section of the Forensic Department said he analysed a screw, window latch with three screws, metal clip, a watch and a connecting pin, a button with a white thread, a pants, which was covered with blood, a part of a doormat and a piece of paint.”
and this:
“He (Mazli) said he also did not find any fabric threads at the window frame on the 14th floor, where the Selangor headquarters of the Malaysian Anti-Corruption Commission (MACC) is located.”
So I think you have received a wrong information.from experience the foreign pathologist, if not allowed on the stand, will pass on her observations to Teoh’s group of lawyers. She will tell them what to ask and debunk some of the finding of Dr Khairul.
Honestly, I don’t trust this Khairul fellow. I reckon he has done PM on many lock-up deaths and has never found the police culpable. He is a police frindly pathologist.
Many of these doctors always give finding favourable to the police.
Tell me, was there ever once the police were found culpable for the more than 1500 deaths in police custody?
We have murders covered up by police, doctors, AG chambers, judges and the government.
This people and their progeny will receive Divine retribution for this evil.Death at MACC: My CSI X: The window and Dr Khairul
1. The window at the MACC office on the 14th floor became the issue of contention during the inquest. The forensic expert says that the window is dusty but there were no prints on the window. The floor near the window is carpeted and is also dusty. Dr Khairul in his theory says that TBH committed suicide based on his findings at the window and the condition of the window.
2. Respectfully I have to disagree with Dr Khairul even though I do not have the access to the information and material that Dr Khairul had. Despite the minimal information initially and with the latest information that is being released via the inquest, I find that Dr Khairul suggestion that TBH may have commit suicide a little bit farfetched.
3. I believe Dr Khairul and I are on the same page with regards to the cause of death which is immediate death upon impact from a fall from height. The underlying cause would be massive and sudden blood loss in the chest cavity and the torn heart muscle. His own PM finding rules out the possibility of stroke or heart attack.
4. However I disagree with him on the manner TBH exited the window. From earlier discussion and inquest findings, it is quite certain now that the exited point is the window on the 14th floor where the broken latch and a matching thread from his pants was found.
5. Let us revisit what was said by CI Mazli Jusoh at the Inquest. Among others he said,” he found no visible signs of shoe prints on the window ledge or nearby walls” and “The window frame was dusted for fingerprints but the results were negative because the window was dirty and dusty,” The main crux of the police findings here is that there was dust at the window frames and it has not been disturbed. There were no markings on the window frames as if someone had touched it.
6. Based on Mazli Jusoh statement, it is quite probable that he did not climb out. If he did then, there would be marks on the window frames. It is almost impossible for someone of TBH height to climb out the window without holding to the frames. He is not that tall and has a body length of 174cm (5 feet and 8 inch).
7. Based on DSP Shahrul statement at the inquest where he said that he measured the window size which is 132cm in height and 82 cm in width. From the pictures on the internet, I measured the pixel points and estimated that the height of the window base from the floor is about 85cm. This rough measurement basically tells us that the window height is about 49% of Teoh body length.
8. It would be difficult for anyone of that size to climb out of the window without holding on to the side of the windows. The measurement ratio between the height of the window base from the floor and TBH height alone is conclusive enough that Dr Khairul theory that he had committed suicide is very weak and can be thrown out of the window.
9. Personally, I feel Deo has been an unfair to Dr Khairul. As a doctor, the most he can comment is the nature of the injury, its severity and postulated the cause and time of death. He probably can contribute to the mechanics of the injury. Obviously, he does not have all the pieces of the puzzle. It is a question should have been addressed to the I/O.
10. The absences of any disturbance of dust distribution on the window frames actually strengthen two important points. The first point is that he was either dead or was unconscious at the time he was exiting the window and the second is that there is a strong possibility that was lifted and thrown out of the window.
11. The basis of my argument on Para 10 is based on the fact that if TBH was lifted into the window, that there isn’t any need for anyone touch the frames of the window. Therefore there would be no disturbance in the dust marking on the window frames. This is consistent with what the police finding on the window frames.
12. At the same time, I am not sure how many people read the PM by Dr Khairul. My own observation is that there are a few findings that in my mind may not be associated with the fall. I will dwell more into this matter in the coming days. So far in my mind, based on the PM findings, the many pictures on the internet and the revelation at the inquest, I am more inclined to believe that TBH died while he was in the custody of MACC. I firmly believe that he was dead or unconscious when he exited the window.
Link to Inquest records at AG Chambers website
Disclaimer
The above writing is based on assessment of various images and writings on the mainstream media (MSM) as well as the online media. I am trying to understand the tragedy that took place at Plaza Masalam. It would be great if I have access to MACC office and location where the body was found but without such access, readers can expect some gross margin of error in my writing. Do let me know what the errors are so that we can come to a clear conclusion on what transpired.
police had a hand in the rape and murder of two women in Shopian town in doctors did not take out all required samples from heart and brain of the girl Asiya and her pregnant sister-in-law Neelofar Jan for FSL tests during the postmortem.
read this how the police protect their own kind
SRINAGAR: The Jammu&Kashmir government on Friday admitted that the police had a hand in the rape and murder of two women in Shopian town inThe report, which was submitted to Chief Minister Omar Abdullah on July 8 by Justice (retd) Muzzafar Jan, was vetted by the state law department before taking the decision.Kashmir Valley has been seething after a 17-year-old girl and her 22-year-old sister-in-law were found dead in a stream on May 30 in Shopian. The police and the state government first said the women had drowned.The four suspended police officers in connection with the case will be treated as accused and interrogated by the Special Investigating Team set up by the state government.State finance minister Abdul Rahim Rather changed his government’s stand and told a press conference in Srinagar that a judicial probe had implicated the state police in the murders.Accepting the judicial commission’s recommendation, the state government also announced that a separate case would be registered against the former SP of Shopian Javed Iqbal for allegedly lying on oath before the Commission. Besides Iqbal, the one-member Commission said DySP Rohit Baskota, SHO Shafiq Ahmed and Sub-inspector Gazi Abdul Rehman were also responsible for destruction of evidence.Rather said a complaint had been filed against four police officials for destruction of evidence in the deaths. The state government urged people in the state to remain calm and assured them those found guilty of the murders won’t be spared.Two people have been killed and more than 400 others injured in numerous angry protests and clashes between demonstrators and police, especially in Shopian, 60 kms from Srinagar.Those who use the media filter to try to understand what is happening in Kashmir should realize they’re looking at a shadow play. A curtain lies: A judge who was tasked with investigating the Shopian rapes and killings that snowballed into huge protests and left the governmentred-faced has held the J&K police and the state administration responsible for destroying evidence.In his report submitted on Sunday, Justice Muzaffar Ahmad Jan said the police and civil administration had erased all links that could have helped the panel to reach the culprits. The bodies of the two women, who residents of Shopian, 50 km from Srinagar, claim were raped and then killed by security forces, were found in a lake last month.The panel held four top police officers, including former Shopian SP Javid Iqbal, DSP Rohit Baskot, former SHO Shakil Ahmad and SI Gazi Abdul Karim responsible for trying to hush-up the case and make it look like a case of accidental drowning. Chief minister Omar Abdullah on Monday ordered suspension of the four officers. Javid was recently transferred to Ramban in Jammu following largescale resentment against him in Shopian.After protests erupted, Abdullah on June 1 asked the retired judge to probe the rape and murder that occurred on the intervening night of May 29-30.IG, CID, Farooq Ahmad will hold a departmental inquiry against these police officers, sources said. Jan told TOI that the doctors, who conducted the post-mortem, also tried to hush up the case by holding back the report for six days.He observed scientific officer at the Forensic Science Laboratory Javed Iqbal Hafiz also delayed the submission of certificate containing opinion of the doctors regarding rape. Abdullah has also suspended Hafiz.Jan said the doctors did not take out all required samples from heart and brain of the girl Asiya and her pregnant sister-in-law Neelofar Jan for FSL tests during the postmortem.In the 150-page report, Justice (retired) Jan recommended departmental action and inquiry against the doctors. He also recommended prosecution of Javid Iqbal Hafiz, scientific officer of FSL, for obstructing and delaying investigations by deliberately keeping the FSL report with himself.He also recommended disciplinary action against former deputy commissioner Shopian Mohammad Ramzan Thokar for inaction.“I have recommended stern disciplinary action against the former deputy commissioner Shopian for not giving orders for registering an FIR,” Justice Jan said. Quoting the medical report, Justice Jan said the rape was committed on the women before they were killed.between events and us. What is played out on the screen depends on who manipulates the sources of light.
SRINAGAR: The Jammu&Kashmir government on Friday admitted that the police had a hand in the rape and murder of two women in Shopian town in
The report, which was submitted to Chief Minister Omar Abdullah on July 8 by Justice (retd) Muzzafar Jan, was vetted by the state law department before taking the decision.
Kashmir Valley has been seething after a 17-year-old girl and her 22-year-old sister-in-law were found dead in a stream on May 30 in Shopian. The police and the state government first said the women had drowned.
The four suspended police officers in connection with the case will be treated as accused and interrogated by the Special Investigating Team set up by the state government.
State finance minister Abdul Rahim Rather changed his government’s stand and told a press conference in Srinagar that a judicial probe had implicated the state police in the murders.
Accepting the judicial commission’s recommendation, the state government also announced that a separate case would be registered against the former SP of Shopian Javed Iqbal for allegedly lying on oath before the Commission. Besides Iqbal, the one-member Commission said DySP Rohit Baskota, SHO Shafiq Ahmed and Sub-inspector Gazi Abdul Rehman were also responsible for destruction of evidence.
Rather said a complaint had been filed against four police officials for destruction of evidence in the deaths. The state government urged people in the state to remain calm and assured them those found guilty of the murders won’t be spared.
Two people have been killed and more than 400 others injured in numerous angry protests and clashes between demonstrators and police, especially in Shopian, 60 kms from Srinagar.
Those who use the media filter to try to understand what is happening in Kashmir should realize they’re looking at a shadow play. A curtain lies: A judge who was tasked with investigating the Shopian rapes and killings that snowballed into huge protests and left the government
red-faced has held the J&K police and the state administration responsible for destroying evidence.
In his report submitted on Sunday, Justice Muzaffar Ahmad Jan said the police and civil administration had erased all links that could have helped the panel to reach the culprits. The bodies of the two women, who residents of Shopian, 50 km from Srinagar, claim were raped and then killed by security forces, were found in a lake last month.
The panel held four top police officers, including former Shopian SP Javid Iqbal, DSP Rohit Baskot, former SHO Shakil Ahmad and SI Gazi Abdul Karim responsible for trying to hush-up the case and make it look like a case of accidental drowning. Chief minister Omar Abdullah on Monday ordered suspension of the four officers. Javid was recently transferred to Ramban in Jammu following largescale resentment against him in Shopian.
After protests erupted, Abdullah on June 1 asked the retired judge to probe the rape and murder that occurred on the intervening night of May 29-30.
IG, CID, Farooq Ahmad will hold a departmental inquiry against these police officers, sources said. Jan told TOI that the doctors, who conducted the post-mortem, also tried to hush up the case by holding back the report for six days.
He observed scientific officer at the Forensic Science Laboratory Javed Iqbal Hafiz also delayed the submission of certificate containing opinion of the doctors regarding rape. Abdullah has also suspended Hafiz.
Jan said the doctors did not take out all required samples from heart and brain of the girl Asiya and her pregnant sister-in-law Neelofar Jan for FSL tests during the postmortem.
In the 150-page report, Justice (retired) Jan recommended departmental action and inquiry against the doctors. He also recommended prosecution of Javid Iqbal Hafiz, scientific officer of FSL, for obstructing and delaying investigations by deliberately keeping the FSL report with himself.
He also recommended disciplinary action against former deputy commissioner Shopian Mohammad Ramzan Thokar for inaction.
“I have recommended stern disciplinary action against the former deputy commissioner Shopian for not giving orders for registering an FIR,” Justice Jan said. Quoting the medical report, Justice Jan said the rape was committed on the women before they were killed.
between events and us. What is played out on the screen depends on who manipulates the sources of light.READMORE CLICK BELOW
→ Leave a CommentCategories: Uncategorized
No comments:
Post a Comment